ManyKeep Decision Hub › Cloud, NAS & Self-Hosting Hub › AWS EC2 vs. Bare-Metal Server TCO Calculator

AWS EC2 vs. Hetzner & Bare-Metal Server TCO Calculator: 3-Year vCPU, RAM, NVMe & Egress Bandwidth Repatriation Audit

Hyperscaler cloud compute (AWS EC2, GCP, Azure) charges a 3x to 6x markup on steady-state vCPU and RAM, bills $0.08/GB-month for EBS GP3 block storage, and levies an $0.09/GB outbound egress bandwidth tax ($90 per TB after 100GB) while dedicated Ryzen/EPYC bare-metal servers from Hetzner, OVHcloud, and colocation providers bundle 20TB+ of monthly traffic and raw NVMe RAID at fixed monthly rates. Audit your exact 36-month cloud repatriation savings after pricing in DevOps HA/failover engineering hours.

1. Compute Tier, EBS NVMe Storage & Egress Traffic

Bare-metal dedicated physical Ryzen/EPYC cores deliver ~1.4x–1.8x higher sustained passmark per thread than shared cloud vCPUs.
Tip: Include at least 2–3 bare-metal nodes for BGP/Keepalived HA failover and zero-downtime rolling deploys.
Note: AWS Savings Plans discount EC2 compute only; they NEVER discount EBS GP3 storage or $0.09/GB data egress.
AWS EBS GP3 bills ~$0.08/GB-mo + snapshot overhead; Bare-Metal includes dual enterprise NVMe RAID1 drives in base price.

2. Outbound Egress Bandwidth & DevOps HA Overhead

AWS/GCP/Azure charge ~$0.09/GB ($90/TB) beyond 100GB free tier; Hetzner/OVH bundle 20TB/node free (~$1.10/TB overage).
Default $78/mo reflects a 16-core/32-thread Ryzen 7 / 64GB DDR5 ECC / 2×1TB NVMe server + $45 one-time setup fee.
Extra hours/mo managing Proxmox/K3s/Talos Linux, WireGuard mesh, smartd NVMe health alerts, and PostgreSQL Patroni failover.
Set to 0 for Solo Founder Sweat-Equity / Homelab mode; $75–$120/hr for commercial SRE labor allocation.
INFRASTRUCTURE TCO VERDICT

Repatriate to Bare-Metal / Hetzner Cluster

Loading 36-month AWS EC2 vs. Bare-Metal repatriation audit…

3-Yr Hyperscaler Cloud Bill
$86,875
EC2 Compute + EBS GP3 + Egress Tax
3-Yr Bare-Metal + DevOps TCO
$26,913
Dedicated hardware + 216 hrs SRE labor
3-Yr Cloud Egress Tax Penalty
$32,076
$0.09/GB AWS outbound vs 20TB/node included
Net 3-Yr Repatriation Savings
+$59,962
69.0% net 36-month TCO reduction

What Would Change the Answer? (Cloud Repatriation Break-Even Thresholds)

  • DevOps Labor Break-Even Ceiling: Even at $85/hr, your team would have to burn 25.5 extra hours every single month (918 hours over 3 years) on bare-metal maintenance before AWS EC2 breaks even.
  • The Hidden Egress Multiplier: Outbound bandwidth alone accounts for 36.9% of your 3-year AWS bill. Placing Cloudflare CDN or Cloudflare R2 in front of EC2 cuts egress, or moving to Hetzner/OVH eliminates the first 20TB/node entirely.
  • When Hyperscaler Cloud Still Wins: Stay on AWS/GCP if you have active startup credits, require spiky 10x auto-scaling within 90 seconds, or need SOC2/HIPAA managed RDS/Aurora compliance without an internal Linux SRE.
Running Smaller Single-Node Workloads or Comparing Managed PaaS vs. Unmanaged VPS?
Calculate your Implicit SysAdmin Hourly Wage across initial Linux/Docker hardening, monthly patching, and unplanned downtime risk.
Open DIY VPS vs. Managed Hosting Calculator →
Sponsored Resource Slot • Zero-CLS 280px Reserved Container

3-Year Infrastructure TCO Matrix: AWS EC2 vs. DigitalOcean/Linode vs. Hetzner Dedicated vs. Colocation

Below is the empirical 36-month cost comparison for a single node (plus 1 TB NVMe storage and 10 TB/month outbound egress bandwidth) across four infrastructure tiers before DevOps labor.

Workload Tier (+ 1TB NVMe & 10TB/mo Egress)AWS EC2 (1-Yr Savings Plan + EBS GP3 + $0.09/GB Egress)DigitalOcean / Linode Dedicated CPU VPSHetzner / OVHcloud Dedicated Bare-Metal (20TB Incl.)Owned 1U Server Colocation (3-Yr Amortized CapEx + Rack)
8 vCPU / 32 GB RAM
(m7i.2xlarge vs Ryzen 7 8c/16t)
$42,444 / 3 yrs
($209/mo compute + $80 EBS + $890/mo egress)
$11,880 / 3 yrs
($240/mo VM + $50/mo extra bandwidth)
$1,989 / 3 yrs
($54/mo AX42 + $45 setup • $0 egress fee)
$5,450 / 3 yrs
($1,850 1U hardware + $100/mo 1U colo)
16 vCPU / 64 GB RAM
(m7i.4xlarge vs Ryzen 9 / EPYC 16c)
$49,968 / 3 yrs
($418/mo compute + $80 EBS + $890/mo egress)
$20,520 / 3 yrs
($480/mo VM + $30/mo extra bandwidth)
$2,853 / 3 yrs
($78/mo AX52 + $45 setup • $0 egress fee)
$6,900 / 3 yrs
($2,580 1U hardware + $120/mo 1U colo)
32 vCPU / 128 GB RAM + 10TB Egress
(m7i.8xlarge vs Ryzen 9 7950X3D / EPYC 24c)
$65,016 / 3 yrs
($836/mo compute + $80 EBS + $890/mo egress)
$37,800 / 3 yrs
($960/mo VM + $10/mo extra bandwidth)
$5,013 / 3 yrs
($138/mo AX102 + $45 setup • $0 egress fee)
$9,480 / 3 yrs
($3,720 1U hardware + $160/mo 1U colo)

Engineering Methodology: How Cloud Repatriation TCO Is Calculated

Basecamp (37signals), Ahrefs, and Prismatic documented 60% to 75% infrastructure savings after repatriating steady-state compute and NVMe databases from AWS EC2 to dedicated hardware. Our calculator models all four components of the 36-month infrastructure equation:

  1. Compute Reservation Normalization: We benchmark AWS EC2 M7i/C7i generation instances across On-Demand (1.0x), 1-Year Compute Savings Plans (0.71x), and 3-Year All-Upfront Reserved Instances (0.54x) multiplied across your active node count $N$ over 36 months.
  2. EBS GP3 Block Storage & Snapshot Overhead: Unlike bare-metal servers that ship with 2×1TB or 2×2TB datacenter Gen4 NVMe drives in hardware/mdadm RAID1 at $0 extra monthly cost, hyperscalers bill $0.08/GB-month for EBS GP3 plus ~$0.02/GB-month in incremental snapshot retention ($0.10/GB-month effective rate).
  3. The Outbound Egress Bandwidth Tax ($0.09/GB): AWS, GCP, and Azure charge ~$90 per TB for outbound internet egress beyond the first 100GB/month. Bare-metal providers (Hetzner, OVHcloud) bundle 20TB to 30TB of 1Gbps unmetered traffic per server and charge only ~$1.10/TB for overages.
  4. DevOps HA & Failover Labor Allocation: Because bare-metal hardware does not self-heal via an AWS Auto Scaling Group API call without orchestration, we add $36 \times H_{\text{devops}} \times W_{\text{hourly}}$ to the bare-metal TCO to price in Proxmox/Kubernetes cluster maintenance, hardware replacement runbooks, and off-site Borg/Restic backups.
Engineering & Financial Oversight: This cloud repatriation and bare-metal TCO model is architected and reviewed by the ManyKeep Engineering & Editorial Team. Read our Engineering & Financial Disclaimer.
Embed This AWS EC2 vs. Bare-Metal Server TCO Calculator on Your Engineering Blog (1-Click Snippet):